I believe that we are beings composed
of two substances like Descartes argued. However, unlike him I believe that
these two substances are completely interrelated with one another,
which is also known as interactionism. If it wasn't for our ability to
combine both our physical assets (like the brain) with our mental ones (like
the mind) we wouldn't be able to make simple decisions such as what to write
for this blog.
Due to the lack of knowledge during
Descartes' time as to how the brain works, a lot was not properly understood
(i.e the example given in the reading about the pineal gland). But now with the
technology available to us, we can comprehend more about the way in which the
brain works and all the connections that must happen in order for us to
complete simple tasks.
One way in which the brain and the
mind work together can be seen in people who have had accidents and suffer
trauma. Depending on the severity of the injury, some people have described feeling
trapped in their own bodies. In a documentary “Coma” by HBO, a patient by the
name of Tom is seen struggling to get his body follow simple commands such as “close
your hand”. In an interview done a few months after he had regained both mental
and physical strength, he explained how even though early on in his recovery
from a coma he could understand what was asked of him; he still wasn't able to
get his body to do what he wanted.
If we go back to Descartes’ argument
of interactionism, one can see that in the previous example Tom needed both his
physical asset (his brain) and his metal (his mind) in order to be able to
complete the tasks that were asked of him. I strongly believe that one does not
work without the other and with the help of both we become the people that we
are.
I like the example you use in this post. It really helps to bring out the significance of the issue.
ReplyDelete